Welcome to Amistad Insurance, your reliable local agency serving Sarasota, Florida, and nearby Gulf Coast communities. With over 16 years of trusted service, we specialize in crafting personalized insurance plans that fit your lifestyle — whether you’re a homeowner, a driver, or a small business owner.
From bustling downtown Sarasota to the quiet neighborhoods of Siesta Key and Venice, our licensed agents deliver peace of mind through expert guidance, transparent pricing, and responsive local support.
Request a free quote today and discover why so many Floridians trust Amistad Insurance for smarter protection.
Affordable, responsive, and honest. I recommend them to anyone in Sarasota.
Amistad helped me find better home coverage with great rates. The Sarasota team was amazing!
Super professional service and quick responses. They made getting auto insurance effortless.
Drive with confidence. Our auto plans protect you from collisions, theft, and unforeseen events — with quick claims and affordable premiums.
Shield your property from hurricanes, fires, and everyday risks. Our policies include optional flood coverage and flexible payment plans.
Get coverage for your belongings, personal liability, and rental property. Simple, fast, and affordable for Sarasota renters.
Secure your company’s future with tailored business insurance — covering vehicles, liability, and employees under one trusted agency.
Whether on the water or open road, our customized recreational insurance keeps your adventures worry-free.
